From: Robert Ho (ho3@pacific.net.sg)
Subject: RH: How law began
This is the only article in this thread
View: Original Format
Newsgroups: soc.culture.singapore
Date: 2004-07-10 16:02:33 PST
RH:
1. Above many courts of law is usually a statue of a woman holding a
scale in one hand and a sword in the other, usually blindfolded to
indicate that she is blind to persons of status or privilege. It is a
nice artistic presentation but sorely mistaken in point, like many
works of art created by artistic souls who do not understand the true
nature of what they are portraying. In this case, if you think that
law is the handmaiden of justice, you are sorely mistaken. Like many
myths that mankind has invented to glorify its sordid acts, like
democracy, for instance, this notion of law being justice is totally,
totally wrong.
2. How so?
3. Well, to begin with, law is not justice. I would define justice as a sense of natural justice that almost all of us are born with,
intuitive and instinctive. From early childhood, we know that if we
are good, we usually receive praise or some other tangible reward. Or, more to the point, if we are bad, we receive a scolding or even a
caning. BUT IF WE ARE CANED WITHOUT HAVING DONE ANYTHING BAD, WE
RESENT THE CANING LIKE HELL, BURNING WITH A SENSE OF INJUSTICE.
4. There, the sense of justice and injustice is inborn.
5. The sense of justice or natural justice is also ingrained in us
from early childhood by the inevitable squabbles with siblings. When
food or something nice like candies are dispensed to us children, we
all expect a fair share. If one gets more and the other/s less, the
shortchanged sibling raises hell. I now deem to have proven my point,
that the sense of natural justice is inborn and not taught. I believe
monkey studies should also prove my point.
6. What then, is law? if it is not a direct derivation of justice?
7. For that, let us look at the most famous laws of all, the 10
Commandments.
8. These seem to be the handmaiden of justice. Do they not enforce a
conduct that is just? Are they not justice?
9. No, no, no, no, NO!
10. Firstly, most of them begin with "Thou shalt not...". In other
words, they are commands or orders. Ah, orders! We begin to see the
light.
11. In other words, laws are orders, usually prohibitions. Usually
all negatives. Many with prescribed penalties for infringements of
these orders.
12. We begin to see the light.
13. If the 10 Commandments are orders, so, too, are all other laws,
from the most ancient to the most modern. This gives us a clue as to
the true nature of law.
14. In other words, law is an instrument of control, NOT JUSTICE!
With something of a blinding flash, we realise that laws are designed
to control people, NOT to create a just and equal society.
15. Now, think back to the 10 Commandments. God gave Moses the
tablets so as to enforce his will upon his people. In exactly the same way, politicians [who make the laws] devise laws to control their people and not for any fancy notions of creating justice for all. And since all politicians are corrupt and self-serving, this means that laws are never just in the natural justice sense of the word.
Politicians devise laws to control their people and populations, to
enforce their will exactly like God gave Moses 10 Commandments to
enforce his will upon his people. In so-called democracies, the need
to get re-elected does somewhat ameliorate the corrupt natures of the
rulers so they do need to temper their laws somewhat, but still the
true nature of their laws are also for social control, not justice.
16. Why is law necessary to enforce the will of the ruler? Cannot he
simply dictate his will?
17. Well, in the olden days, long, long ago, that may have been
exactly the case. Long ago, the head of the tribe probably summarily
ordered the people around and gave verbal instructions as to what
cannot be done, for example, criminally defame him, for instance.
18. But with time and growing complexity of tribal life, no single
chief could go around giving orders and deciding who should live and
who should be tormented and tortured. It was simply too much work. So, law was invented as a generalised form of the orders of the chief.
Instead of the chief having to be brought to each alleged evildoer to
decide whether he was innocent or guilty, to be released or punished,
a written set of laws would become the generalised orders or commands
of the chief. And when the chief himself could not personally decide
all the cases, judges were invented to take his place as the decider
of guilt and punishment.
19. In time, this became law. Notice that even in our modern times,
the phrase "law and order" often go together. This close relationship
of the two shows that order is the true nature of law and not justice.
In fact, we often are puzzled at why and how some obviously guilty
persons are let off free while others receive what we feel to be
inordinate sentences. This, again, indicates that natural justice is
no longer, if it had ever been, the handmaiden of law but that order
and commands are -- in short, the instruments of social control.
20. By now, we have an elaborate system of law and the procedures of
the court. Judges even wear special gowns or even wigs to appear
infallible or to project an aura of superhuman ability. Pooh, pooh.
Underneath, they are often no smarter than you or me, especially me.
21. To sum up, if you ever had the airy fairy notion that law is
justice or has anything even remotely to do with justice, forget it!
Law's first and only purpose is social control, to enforce the will of the guy in charge, or the biggest bully. Even the playground bully
makes laws, such as how often to pay him money and how much. Or to be
careful not to talk bad about him or he will beat you up. This is the
true nature of law. If I have raised some doubts in you about the true nature of law, and set you thinking, then my time spent in writing this essay will have been very worth while.
Robert Ho
11 Jul 04
Singapore 0703
http://groups.google.com/groups?q=RH:+How+law+began&hl=en&lr=&ie=UTF-8&group=soc.culture.singapore.*&selm=c443dfe.0407101502.6833937b%40posting.google.com&rnum=1
RH: ROBERT's ALMOST-COMPLETE ARCHIVE OF WORKS..... My other blog is "I came, I saw, I solved it" at http://i-came-i-saw-i-solved-it.blogspot.com/.......... Robert Ho REQUEST FOR STATEMENTS at http://roberthorequestforstatements.blogspot.com/2011/01/robert-ho-request-for-statements.html
Blog Archive
-
▼
2007
(118)
-
▼
February
(117)
- RH MicroStories
- RH: Are God/s developed from Ghosts?
- RH: Inflight Immigration and Other Clearances for ...
- RH: Business Opportunity for Radio Stations in Joh...
- RH: How China can Deter a US Attack [Proxy Target ...
- RH: Demographics-based Economics
- RH: "Flexible Interiors Concept" for Airbus A380
- RH: The Unchanging Nature of Dictatorships
- RH: Darwinism Revised
- RH: Idea for a China "Atoms for Peace" Programme
- RH: Robert's Ideas Paradoxes
- RH: How Law began
- RH: How to force Israel to its knees
- RH: Fostering a EU Culture and Identity
- RH: Latency, Low-Base & Tiny-Country Effects
- RH: Robert's Thoughts on SARS
- RH: Changing Mindsets and Set Minds
- RH: Solve this SARS problem and win $10m
- RH: Government by Referendum
- RH: Singaporeans soon to be extinct
- RH: Tree Leaves Vacuumer
- RH: Father Figures and the Moses Complex
- RH: Idea to prevent Bio-invasion from ships Ballas...
- RH: A Future-proof PC, Sony?
- RH: UK Telephone Boxes as Smoking Boxes
- RH: London and other DoughNuts in the making
- RH: An Idea to end Spam
- RH: How to conduct cheap, accurate Political Polls
- "RH: Defending against manned/unmanned/stealth war...
- RH: New Ideas to deter a US/any invasion
- RH: Why Law is a disreputable subject
- RH: Robert's definition of "Idea"
- RH: Petrol stations to become Multi-Fuel Stations?
- RH: Why Singapore should NOT have a govt
- RH: Idea to 'Turn Oceans into FreshWater'
- RH: Robert's TorchLight Effect
- RH: Why US high tech cannot win wars
- RH: :Philosophy of Law all wrong and how to put it...
- RH: Leeconomic growth, measured in GNP, mediocre a...
- RH: New Ideas to deter a US/any invasion
- RH: Robert's Complete Case against Leeconomics [Main]
- RH: Idea to almost eliminate computer viruses
- RH: GDP and other Lies...
- RH: Why Foreign Talent policy cannot work
- RH: How ASEAN can host an Olympics
- RH: Why Inflation should be 0 or even Negative
- RH: Why US produces few IDEAs but many Gizmos, thu...
- RH: How China can deter a US attack with Space Junk
- RH: Robert's Thoughts on American bestiality 6
- RH: How Singapore will End scenarios
- RH: Robert's Dictum of Public Service
- RH: Robert's Thoughts on War 6
- RH: Robert HO's Theory of Brain Language
- Hiring Foreign Talent - How many Jobs do we Lose?
- Appeal against WP Disqualification
- GOH Chok Tong lies - Ministers who lose can remain
- Break the Law - like your PAP Leaders
- An Unusual Challenge
- Dirty Bombs
- US Deputy Sheriff in S.E.Asia
- sex.com and SFD
- PAP bans Mirrors
- Let Ghosts contest GE
- Email the SM, PM and DPM
- Letter to a Son
- PAP afraid of Truth
- PAP should throw Black Sheep out
- Who hacked NSP's Mailing Lists?
- Nominate CHEE for NMP
- You can't eat Democracy, but...
- Opposition up against past; PAP up against future
- Handbook for the Voter
- Karl Marx on Singapore
- May Day! May Day!
- Cult of Infallibility
- Crystal-ball Gazing
- Man who cried Wolf
- Good Men don't join the PAP
- Handphones against the PAP
- Outwit the PAP
- Opposition should do Business
- Computer Virus Wanted
- Overseas Votes
- Chinese New Year Story
- Albinocracy and Autisticracy
- Sweepers can help
- No Privacy
- Stockholm Syndrome
- Lesson from Kursk
- Deja Vu
- Letter from the Future
- For Better or Worse
- Referendum, Please!
- The Big 'S'
- Mayor who shagged me
- Jingoism Fatique
- Cruel Punishment
- About Safire's Article
- Equal Justice for all
- Something for Physicists to Philosphers
-
▼
February
(117)
Labels
- "DIRECTORs CID + IMH CRIMINALLY GUILTY"
- "RH: Defending against manned/unmanned/stealth warplanes and Land attacks"
- A second Singapore: Why we succeed and fail
- About Safire's article
- Albinocracy and Autisticracy
- An Unusual Challenge
- Appeal against WP Disqualification
- Break the Law - like your PAP Leaders
- Chinese New Year Story
- Computer Virus Wanted
- Cruel Punishment
- Crystal-ball Gazing
- Cult of Infallibility
- Deja Vu
- Dirty Bombs
- Email the SM PM and DPM
- Equal Justice for all
- Filmmaker Martyn SEE interviews Robert HO
- For Better or Worse
- Francis Seow's article
- GOH Chok Tong lies - Ministers who lose can remain
- Good Men don't join the PAP
- Government by taxation
- Handbook for the Voter
- Handphones against the PAP
- Hiring Foreign Talent - How many Jobs do we Lose
- ICONOCLASSING Pt 2
- ICONOCLASSING Pt 3 or RH Zero Sum Game Theory
- ICONOCLASSING SINGAPORE GDP MYTHS
- Idea: Why UFO Aliens havent contacted us
- Incrementalist or Infinitian
- Interpretation of the Amendment Bill
- Jingoism Fatique
- Karl Marx on Singapore
- LEE Suan Yew Award
- Lesson from Kursk
- Let Ghosts contest GE
- Letter from the Future
- Letter to a Son
- Letter to PM Blair
- Making home movies is this easy
- Man who cried Wolf
- May Day
- Mayor who shagged me
- MVC a 100% PAP idea
- No Privacy
- Nominate CHEE for NMP
- Opposition should do Business
- Opposition up against past; PAP up against future
- Original short Singapore political jokes
- Original Singapore political jokes
- Original Singapore political quotes
- Outwit the PAP
- Overseas Votes
- PAP afraid of Truth
- PAP bans Mirrors
- PAP should throw Black Sheep out
- Proposal to build Retirement Homes in Johor Baru
- Referendum Please
- RH MicroStories
- RH: "Flexible Interiors Concept" for Airbus A380
- RH: A Future-proof PC Sony
- RH: An Idea to end Spam
- RH: Are God/s developed from Ghosts?
- RH: Business Opportunity for Radio Stations in Johor and Batam/Bintan
- RH: Changing Mindsets and Set Minds
- RH: Darwinism Revised
- RH: Demographics-based Economics
- RH: Father Figures and the Moses Complex
- RH: Fostering a EU Culture and Identity
- RH: GDP and other Lies...
- RH: Government by Referendum
- RH: How ASEAN can host an Olympics
- RH: How China can Deter a US Attack [Proxy Target Strategy] 2
- RH: How China can deter a US attack with Space Junk
- RH: How Law began
- RH: How Singapore will End scenarios
- RH: How to conduct cheap accurate Political Polls
- RH: How to force Israel to its knees
- RH: Idea for a China "Atoms for Peace" Programme
- RH: Idea to 'Turn Oceans into FreshWater'
- RH: Idea to almost eliminate computer viruses
- RH: Idea to prevent Bio-invasion from ships Ballast Water
- RH: Inflight Immigration and Other Clearances for Airbus A380
- RH: Latency Low-Base and Tiny-Country Effects
- RH: Leeconomic growth measured in GNP mediocre all along
- RH: London and other DoughNuts in the making
- RH: New ideas to deter a US/any invasion
- RH: Petrol stations to become Multi-Fuel Stations
- RH: Philosophy of Law all wrong and how to put it right
- RH: Robert HO's Theory of Brain Language
- RH: Robert's Complete Case against Leeconomics [Main]
- RH: Robert's definition of "Idea"
- RH: Robert's Dictum of Public Service
- RH: Robert's Ideas Paradoxes
- RH: Robert's Thoughts on American bestiality 6
- RH: Robert's Thoughts on SARS
- RH: Robert's Thoughts on War 6
- RH: Robert's TorchLight Effect
- RH: Singaporeans soon to be extinct
- RH: Solve this SARS problem and win $10m
- RH: The Unchanging Nature of Dictatorships
- RH: Trees Leaves Vacuumer
- RH: UK Telephone Boxes as Smoking Boxes
- RH: Why Foreign Talent policy cannot work
- RH: Why Inflation should be 0 or even Negative
- RH: Why Law is a disreputable subject
- RH: Why Singapore should NOT have a govt
- RH: Why US high tech cannot win wars
- RH: Why US produces few IDEAs but many Gizmos thus bad for world
- Samizdat and Samizdis
- sex.com and SFD
- Sneak preview' of LKY's second book of Memoirs
- Something for Physicists to Philosophers
- Stockholm Syndrome
- Sweepers can help
- The Big 'S'
- THE MOST COMPLETE RUBBISHING OF LEEconomics EVER
- Tom Clancy's next novel
- US Deputy Sheriff in S.E.Asia
- Vote out 21 politicians and transform Singapore
- When to break the law
- Who hacked NSP's Mailing Lists
- Why pay Singapore Ministers huge salaries
- You can't eat Democracy
About Me
- Robert HO nric S0197974D
- My archive of works is at http://i-came-i-saw-i-wrote-it.blogspot.com/